Kris Jenner has flummoxed Kardashian fans with her animated Christmas message – which seems to be missing a member of the family.

The Keeping Up With The Kardashians’ matriarch posted a picture on her Instagram page of several cartoon images of her clan from hit online game Kim Kardashian: Hollywood.

But while the picture clearly shows Kris and her three eldest daughters Kourtney, Kim and Khloe, fans are bemused as to who is the fourth brunette in a Santa hat, standing immediately to Kris’s right in the picture.

Is it Kendall or Kylie Jenner? And if so, why has she only included one of them?

Puzzled fan Freya Cook asked: “Who’s on the left of kourtney???”

While Aimee Bergeronn wrote: “Who are the 2nd and 3rd ones??”

However, Kris has hopefully appeased everybody by posting a second picture on social media. This time it’s a photograph of herself with all five of her daughters, wearing Santa hats and blowing kisses to camera.

Meanwhile, Kim and husband Kanye West have scotched rumours they planned to spend Christmas with baby North in Paris, away from the rest of the family.

The couple were pictured running errands together in Los Angeles the day before Christmas Eve.

A picture of Kim Kardashian and Kanye West at a benefit in New York
Kim Kardashian and Kanye West (Evan Agostini/AP)

Kim and Kanye had recently flown to New York – presumably for some last minute Christmas shopping – and Radar Online had claimed that they would be celebrating the holidays alone in Paris as Kanye didn’t want to be surrounded by too many Kardashians at Christmas.